Scoring Criteria

Each team will receive a score for its video entry, totalled from the scores received in three overall categories:

  • technical compulsory (15%)
  • content (20%)
  • participation (25%)
  • purely subjective (40%)
Subjective criteria will be scored by impartial, independent critics (to be chosen in secrecy!). Objective criteria will be scored by some poor schmuck (i.e. me). The categories are described in detail below.

After the total score for each team is computed, the teams will be ranked and assigned AI Olympic points according to the usual AI Olympic point rules. (5 points for 1st place, 3 points for 2nd place, etc.)


Scoring Guidelines

Technical Compulsory Compulsory
Format interlaced NTSC color miniDV 0 or 5 points
16-bit 2-channel audio 0 or 5 points
Assembly The submission must follow this outline:
TimeSegment
30 sectone & bars
5 secblack
10 sectitle screen
2 secblack
60 seccommercial content
2 secblack
<60 seccredits
+/-10 frames are allowed for each segment
0 or 5 points
Content Criteria
Genre
Japanese: toy
Italian: clothing/perfume/fashion
French: home appliance or consumer electronics
Chinese: sports event
0-5 points
assessed by how well the video fits into that genre (not necessarily how well the product matches the genre!)
Vegetable
Japanese:carrot
Italian:acorn squash
French:potato
Chinese:tomato
0-5 points
assessed by how well the vegetable is integrated into the production
Quotation
Japanese: "Little surprises around every corner, but nothing dangerous!"
Italian: "A little nonsense now and then is relished by the wisest men."
French: "The suspense is terrible. I hope it will last."
Chinese: "Where is fancy bred, in the heart or in the head?"
0-5 points
assessed by how well the quotation is integrated into the production
Wildcards Random bonus points for footage of:
  • Ross Perot (1 pt)
  • chia-pet (1 pt)
  • George Peppard (1 pt)
  • James MacArthur (1 pt)
  • 6.001 lecture (1 pt)
  • Michael Dertouzos, telling a joke in his office (5 pts)
  • Silvio Micali, telling a joke in his office (5 pts)
  • the Chevrolet Corvair (1 pt)
  • Cyndi Lauper (1 pt)
  • a teammate clothed only in whipped cream (2 pts)
  • a lizard (1 pt)
  • a ball of twine (1 pt)
  • a cat sleeping on a dog (2 pt)
  • Pope John Paul II (1 pt)
  • Scott Baio, as "Charles" (1 pt)
  • Scott Baio, as "Cha-Chi" (1 pt)
  • a Ford Festiva (1 pt)
  • a waterfall (1 pt)
  • smoked salmon (1 pt)
  • a train colliding with a school bus (2 pt)
  • any prime minister of Canada (1 pt)
  • exploding firecracker (1 pt)
  • spilling milk (1 pt)
  • pigeons eating bread crumbs (1 pt)
  • commuters riding the Orange Line (1 pt)
  • Carl DeMarcken (2 pts)
0-5 points (max)
This must be video footage; stills are not acceptable.
Participation Criteria
Participation per capita team members on screen/sound 0-20 points
Participation Bonus bonus for creative use of participation 0-5 points
Purely Subjective Criteria
Technical Merit quality of video and audio professionalism 0-10 points
Attention Fixation how riveting is the video? 0-10 points
Product Recall do you remember, or even know, what the product is? 0-10 points
Sharkey Test Ask yourself the following:
"Would I rather have had my life cut short by 60 seconds, instead of watching that commercial?"
0-10 points

Got that? Good, now go back to the "A Word From Our Sponsors" homepage.